Watch this mesmerizing video of butterfly scales forming inside a chrysalis
Larger, overlapping scales in red and green begin to form their structural details midway through development.
Larger, overlapping scales in red and green begin to form their structural details midway through development.Anthony McDougal and Sungsam Kang
A butterfly's beginnings are wondrous. Gently nestled in its cocoon, a caterpillar transforms into a fairylike creature with meticulously laid out, iridescent scales layered upon each wing. Piece by piece, scientists have been putting together how the magic of that metamorphosis happens.
And they've just unlocked another step: scale formation.
Peering directly into a morphing caterpillar's chrysalis -- one on its way to becoming a painted lady butterfly -- a group of scientists from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology recorded the insect's scales during its transformation. The stunning footage and selected images were published in the journal PNAS on Monday.
Get the CNET Science newsletter
Unlock the biggest mysteries of our planet and beyond with the CNET Science newsletter. Delivered Mondays.
But butterfly wings are more than just beautiful. Understanding their schematics could ultimately benefit constructed materials like windows and thermal systems and even bring an ethereal quality to textiles. "Previous studies provide compelling snapshots at select stages of development; unfortunately, they don't reveal the continuous timeline and sequence of what happens as scale structures grow," Mathias Kolle, an associate professor of mechanical engineering at MIT and co-author of the study, said in a statement. "We needed to see more to start understanding it better."
First, the researchers carefully cut into a caterpillar's paper-thin chrysalis as it began its transformation. They then peeled off a single cuticle, or covering, of the developing wing and exposed the budding scales underneath. Jackpot.
But to keep the soon-to-be baby butterfly safe, they placed a transparent covering over the incision. That way, the caterpillar could continue to naturally evolve while the team maintained an awesome view. "This paper focuses on what's on the surface of the butterfly wing...but underneath the surface, we can also see cells putting down roots like carrots and sending out connections to other roots," Anthony McDougal, a researcher at MIT's Department of Mechanical Engineering and lead author of the study, notes. "There's communication underneath the surface as cells organize, and on the surface, scales are forming."
"We can visualize all of it -- which is really beautiful to see." To isolate the translucent scale structures, the team used a "speckled field" to highlight every airy, colorful flake. Rather than employ a classic light beam, which tends to be wide and could damage scales through UV radiation, they shined tiny specks of light at specific points.
"A speckled field is like thousands of fireflies that generate a field of illumination points," Peter So, a professor of mechanical engineering and biological engineering at MIT, said. "Using this method, we can isolate the light coming from different layers, and can reconstruct the information to map, efficiently, a structure in 3D." The result? Breathtaking.
A depth scan through the wing scales of a pupa, or transforming caterpillar, that has completed 83% of its metamorphosis.
The left image shows the amount of light reflected by the scales, while the phase information on the right shows finer gradations of how far the light traveled to the scales.Anthony McDougal and Sungsam Kang
While there's a bunch of noise in the footage, primarily toward the top left around the scales' edges, the steps of scale evolution were easily visible. Within a few days, cells started lining up and arranging themselves in a shingle-like pattern where some were tucked beneath others. As they continued to grow, they formed their characteristic ridges in an unexpected way.
Rather than gradually wrinkle into an accordion shape -- as the researchers suspected would happen -- the scales generated a sudden waviness. The group hopes to delve into the exact mechanism of ridge formation more closely in future projects. "A lot of these stages were understood and seen before, but now we can stitch them all together and watch continuously what's happening, which gives us more information on the detail of how scales form," McDougal said.
From fairytale to reality
Beyond their mystical appeal, butterfly wings are enthralling because they offer an ideal blueprint for many human-made items; their scales, especially, boast a few utilitarian traits.
Two individual scales shown, top left with typical electron microscopy.
Top right and bottom show the scales in more detail with phase imaging.Anthony McDougal and Sungsam Kang
For one, the team says the intricate architecture helps the insect cool down when it's hot and shed moisture on rainy days along their ridges. But perhaps most remarkably, the scales emit color without having any pigment by taking advantage of a concept called structural coloring. In contrast to standard pigments or dyes, which absorb or reflect particular wavelengths of electromagnetic radiation and emit a corresponding color, structural coloring doesn't rely on chemical composition.
Instead, physical structure is key. On butterfly wings, each scale is positioned in such a way that light is uniquely scattered; our eyes take in a specific color associated with that scattering. That's why some shiny insects appear to change color at different angles.
Structural color has already inspired a few different products, such as this sustainable glitter invented by researchers hoping to mitigate the use of microplastics. "This strategy might be used, for example, to give both color and self-cleaning properties to automobiles and buildings," McDougal said. "Now we can learn from butterflies' structural control of these complex, micro-nanostructured materials."
As it turns out, butterflies' wings aren't merely exquisite.
They're serendipitously built from scales that could be the closest thing we have to fairy dust.